The UK Guardian newspaper recently published an interactive ring diagram showing gun regulation by US states. It’s an attractive diagram but makes so many elementary mistakes in charting that it fails to summarize the data in a meaningful way.
Analysis: If the graph makes a single point, it’s that all states regulate whether a weapon is carried in public or not, but the Northeast is the most highly regulated area for guns, while Southeast is the least. Beyond that, it’s not clear what the point of the graph is — how does the user learn more by interacting with the graphic? What are the subtle points of understanding does the user get from the diagram?
Looking closer at the graphic, I find a lot of problems with the execution:
- The categories are heterogeneous: carry in public is one type of regulation vs. what type of gun requires a permit vs. data points on what is regulated (missing firearms, locking devices and points of sales (gun shows, private sales). For regulation, these seem like a jumble of unrelated issues stuffed into one category. The categorization is the most sloppy part of this graph and does not add to the understanding of the issues.
- The underlying data is poorly documented, although there is a companion post as to how the creators struggled to summarize the data (ie fit the data to the visualization they were attempting. There is also a lot missing to annotate methodology: when the graph is scaled by population, is the outermost ring proportional? or entire slice? what’s the relevance of “population”? Wouldn’t it have made more sense to have the slices proportional to gun owners? What is the time frame for the data? Is there a data table and a clear methodology?
- Color choice seems arbitrary and changes for each data category. Does red mean “unrestricted” when referring to regulation but “concealed carry” permitted?
How the chart could be improved:
- Clearly define what the point of the visualization is. Is it to show that there are geographic differences in gun laws? Show how gun regulation impacts states with higher populations? Show that states with fewer gun laws have more/less violent crimes committed with guns?
- Consistent categorization scheme and color scheme. a two tiered category of gun types (hand guns, rifles, etc) and channels (gun shows, gun shops, and private sales) with a simple scale (white= unregulated, light blue = partial regulation, dark blue = full regulation)
- Add a data table and a clear description of methodology used for categorization and how the data fits the categories.
Overall, I like the idea for this graph to display multiple dimensions, but think it is too muddled to provide any insights.
Population pyramids show population data by gender and age group. They are effective in showing changes over time. This chart of Japan demographics through 2050 appeared in The Economist: This shows three pyramids: Male on left, right hand side females from 1950, 2005, and 2050. (2050 is projection based on current trends). From 1950 to 2005, the pyramid …
Infographic at Ginza Station, Tokyo on the Hibya Line. Left hand side shows weekday departures by hour (5am through 12 midnight) by minute. Right hand side shows Saturday and Holiday departures. It’s an effective graphic that also shows that weekdays have more frequent service, especially in the mornings between 8-9am, and it tapers off after …
Is it easier to glean insights from data using a physical model? Most of the advances in technology (data visualization, charting, interactive graphics) have made it much easier to get insights using on-screen imaging. By and large they have replaced physical construction and drawing of charts with rulers, compasses, and inks. But what if we used …
Flow maps show branches of data which form part of a whole and are often used to show derivative products made from a single source. These were quite popular in the early 20th Century to show shipping traffic from ports. In this example it shows the components that contribute to the 3M stock price. Post-its and office produces …
Information-dense charts show multiple relationships in data in a single, chart. They take more time to read/review, but provide deeper insights. This week’s example from R.W Brunskill’Illustrated Handbook of Vernacular Architecture shows the evolution of “vernacular architecture”. Vernacular architecture ” will have been designed by an amateur, probably of the occupier of the intended building and one …
New web service: your.flowingdata enables you to capture events and activities in your life, track and visualize them. The goal is to understand life choices better. It’s an experimental project from Nathan Yao who runs the excellent data visualization site Flowing Data . Perhaps there will evolve into a journal similar to My Life in Graphs
Visualizing multi-select survey questions (where the respondents can provide multiple answers) is challenging to summarize since pie charts and 100% bar charts do not work well since the parts can add up to be more than 100%. In the book Picturing the Uncertain World: How to Understand, Communicate, and Control Uncertainty through Graphical Display, the …
Organizing the chemical elements into regularly recuring categories was a major step in the history of chemisty. The Russian chemist Mendeleev played an important role in creating the modern periodic table, and looking at how he got there provides some ideas for organizing, classifying, and analyzing large data sets. First, the ideas around periodicity evolved over time. …
Venn diagrams are great for understanding how sets intersect and relate to each other, but most don’t indicate quantity. So if you have a set that shows pet ownership (some own dogs, some dogs and fish,etc): With a proportional Venn diagram, you add the dimension of size or count. For example, People who own a dog+cats (ab) would …